Best pizza in the 5 boroughs

Well this thread has gone to page four and this hasn't been said yet, it's driving me crazy.

You do know that pizza is like sex ---- when it's good it's great and when it's bad it's still pretty good.

^^^^^^^^^^^THIS j

Somebody had to say it I guess. Honestly I have a lot more bad pizza nowadays then really high quality stuff.

campgottagopee wrote

You do know that pizza is like sex ---- when it's good it's great and when it's bad it's still pretty good.

And the best women turn into pizza at 2AM

I just googled "best pizza in Upstate NY" and one of the first places that came up was Oakleys in Arkville. For all you Plattekill guys I highly recommend it. It's right on 28 on the left (east bound) in a little shack. You have to park on the side of the road which is sketchy, but it's definitely a cool place. And great food. Pizza is just a part of it. One of the things I find interesting is that the bartender is an old grandmotherly lady who acts more like a 25 year old girl.

Anyone eaten there?

There is too much red in that map, should go no further north than the GW bridge...

campgottagopee wrote

You do know that pizza is like sex ---- when it's good it's great and when it's bad it's still pretty good.

Yet there is some "pizza" that is so bad it makes you sick to think about how you ate it anyway.

Petronio

PeeTex wrote

There is too much red in that map, should go no further north than the GW bridge...

+1

Being from Jersey I bet Snoloco will appreciate my mention of Three Brothers From Italy right on the boardwalk at Seaside Heights. The Shaw! Woot woot!

Good point but I've never had a slice of pizza give me a venarial disease.

raisingarizona wrote

Good point but I've never had a slice of pizza give me a venarial disease.

HA!

campgottagopee wrote

You do know that pizza is like sex ---- when it's good it's great and when it's bad it's still pretty good.

Na.  The pizza out West generally sucks...  Pizza out west is more like jerking off as compared to pizza back East.

nepa wrote

campgottagopee wrote

You do know that pizza is like sex ---- when it's good it's great and when it's bad it's still pretty good.

Na.  The pizza out West generally sucks...  Pizza out west is more like jerking off as compared to pizza back East.

The worst Pizza I have ever had was at a place in Hino Japan, what they though was pizza was - well not. The best way I could describe it as a big round saltine cracker with Velveeta cheese on top.  

I finally got around to trying the place near me that Jason suggested, Deemaria's. It's damn good pizza.

glad you  enjoyed it..entrees are real good too

Bumping on behalf of Sorrentos in Pearl River. Very, very good pizza and tremendous entrees and subs as well.

looks great
I heard great things about this place..need to check it out

No one mentioned Pepe's?  I'm a born and bred New Yorker, but I must say, Pepe's, originally from Ct., is damn good...perhaps the best I've had.

Ethan, Oakley's in Arkville is delicious. IMHO, better than Brio's.

i passed their bill board on i95 yesterday... aren't they famous for the clam pizza?